James Caan became one of Hollywood’s most recognized faces over a career that spanned decades. But before The Godfather, before the fame and the four marriages that followed, there was a first wife. Her name was Dee Jay Mathis, and she remains a quietly noted figure in Caan’s personal history — largely because public information about her is so limited.
This article covers what is actually known: who Dee Jay Mathis is, her connection to James Caan, the timeline of their marriage, their daughter Tara, and her brief background as an actress. Where details are uncertain or unconfirmed, that will be noted clearly.
Who Dee Jay Mathis Is
Dee Jay Mathis is a former actress best known to the public through her marriage to James Caan. She is not a widely documented public figure in her own right, and most references to her appear in celebrity family profiles, genealogy databases, and biographical entries about Caan.
One thing worth clarifying early: her name appears in records under two different spellings — Dee Jay Mathis and Dee Jay Mattis. Both refer to the same person. This inconsistency is part of why searches can return different results depending on which spelling is used.
IMDb lists her birth name as Dorothy Jeanne Mattis, with a listed birth date of August 17, 1941, in Elizabeth, New Jersey. It’s worth noting that this information comes from an entertainment database entry rather than a verified primary record, so it should be treated as database-listed detail rather than confirmed fact.
Her Marriage to James Caan
Dee Jay Mathis and James Caan married in 1961. At that point, Caan was still a young actor working to establish himself in the industry. He had not yet landed the roles that would make him a household name.
Their marriage lasted five years. The couple divorced in 1966. No reliable public source documents the reason for the split, and it would not be appropriate to speculate on it here.
What the timeline does tell us is that their relationship was part of Caan’s earliest adult chapter — before Brian’s Song, before Sonny Corleone, and before the peak of his public life. Sources including Encyclopedia.com, Hollywood Life, and Wikipedia’s entry on James Caan all support this basic timeline.
Their Daughter, Tara Caan
Mathis and Caan had one child together: a daughter named Tara Caan, born in 1964. Tara is James Caan’s first child and the only child Mathis had with him.
It is worth being clear about this, because Caan had four more children from later relationships. His son Scott Caan — himself an actor — tends to be the more recognized name in searches related to Caan’s family. Scott was born during Caan’s later relationship with Sheila Marie Ryan, not during his marriage to Dee Jay Mathis.
Caan’s five children in total were Tara, Scott, Alexander, James Jr., and Jacob. Dee Jay Mathis was the mother of Tara only. People magazine’s profile of Caan’s children and Hollywood Life both confirm this family structure.
Dee Jay Mathis as an Actress
Biographical records — including entries on MyHeritage and IMDb — identify Dee Jay Mathis as an actress. However, the available evidence points to a limited career rather than a prominent or sustained one.
Secondary sources suggest she may have been associated with small roles during the 1960s, but specific film credits are difficult to verify beyond what appears in database entries. Without independent confirmation of individual credits, it would not be accurate to describe her as a Hollywood star or to present a detailed filmography as established fact.
The most honest summary is this: records identify her as an actress, and her work appears to have been modest in scope. She did not go on to build a major public profile in the entertainment industry.
James Caan’s Career and Family After the Divorce
After the divorce from Mathis in 1966, James Caan’s career moved in a very different direction. He went on to marry three more times and became one of the most recognizable actors of his generation.
His most celebrated roles came in the years that followed his first marriage. He earned widespread attention for his performance in Brian’s Song in 1971 and then reached a global audience with his portrayal of Sonny Corleone in The Godfather in 1972. Later films like Thief, Misery, and Elf kept him visible across multiple decades.
On the personal side, Caan married Sheila Marie Ryan in 1976, with whom he had son Scott Caan. He later married Andrea Steinberg and then Linda Stokes. He had children across these relationships — Alexander, James Jr., and Jacob — in addition to his daughter Tara from his marriage to Mathis.
James Caan passed away in July 2022. In the period following his death, renewed public interest in his biography brought some additional attention to the earlier parts of his life, including his first marriage.
Why So Little Is Known About Her
Dee Jay Mathis never pursued a public life in the way that Caan did. She was not a celebrity in her own right, and after her divorce she appears to have remained out of the public eye entirely.
IMDb does list some additional personal details — including a later marriage and a child — but that information is not corroborated by stronger journalistic or biographical sources. Out of caution, those details are not repeated here as confirmed facts.
For anyone researching her through genealogy tools or celebrity family databases, the two name spellings (Mathis and Mattis) are the most useful thing to know. Searching under both can help surface whatever records exist across different platforms.
If you are interested in exploring celebrity biographies, family histories, or related topics, Business Bezel covers a range of profiles and background stories worth browsing.
A Quick Timeline
- 1941: Dee Jay Mathis reportedly born (per IMDb database listing; not independently confirmed)
- 1961: Mathis and James Caan marry
- 1964: Their daughter, Tara Caan, is born
- 1966: Mathis and Caan divorce
Final Thoughts
Dee Jay Mathis occupies a quiet but real place in the story of James Caan’s life. She was his first wife, the mother of his first child, and a woman who — by all available evidence — chose to keep her life private after their marriage ended.
What we know about her is limited: a name with two spellings, a five-year marriage to a man who would become famous, a daughter named Tara, and a background as an actress with a modest career. Beyond that, the reliable record is largely silent.
That silence is not a mystery so much as a straightforward reality. Not everyone connected to a famous person becomes a public figure themselves, and Dee Jay Mathis appears to be a clear example of that.
Also Read:
